7 budget-friendly pizza restaurant • Sorted by best value • Updated March 2026
West by God CoalFired Pizza
West by God CoalFired Pizza delivers excellent wood-fired pizza with a crispy crust that guests rave about, plus the unique addition of on-site axe throwing. The beer wall concept and live music on Friday nights create a fun, lively atmosphere. However, service can be maddeningly inconsistent—some servers are exceptional while others barely acknowledge guests, and delivery orders have experienced significant problems with wrong orders and multi-hour delays.
Pizza at The Cove
Easygoing eatery with wood furnishings & a take-out option turning out pizzas, wings & sides.
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge
This Jersey-style pizzeria off the main Parkway delivers authentic thin-crust pizza that keeps visitors coming back for seconds—literally, with multiple reviewers returning during the same trip. The generous toppings and late-night hours earn consistent praise, though you'll pay tourist-area prices (expect $22+ for a small pizza). A few visitors have encountered significant customer service issues and online ordering problems that warrant caution.
J. Del's Pizza
Modest pizzeria & restaurant offering pasta, subs, calzones & other casual Italian eats.
Big Daddy's Pizzeria
Local chain offering wood-fired, thin-crust pies, plus sandwiches & salads, in a casual setting.
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge
Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas.
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas.
Money-Saving Tips for Pigeon Forge
Visit Pigeon Forge during the off-season (January-March) for the lowest prices on pizza restaurant.
Weekday rates are typically 20-40% lower than weekend rates.
Book 2-3 months in advance for the best selection of budget options.
Check our booking tool for member-only rates that can save an additional 5-15%.
Consider Sevierville for even lower prices — just a short drive away.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest pizza restaurant in Pigeon Forge?
West by God CoalFired Pizza offers great value with a 4.7 rating and $$ pricing. We rank budget options by value score — combining guest ratings with affordability.
How can I save money on pizza restaurant in Pigeon Forge?
Visit during off-season (January-March), book midweek instead of weekends, and use our booking tool to compare prices. Staying in Sevierville instead of Gatlinburg can save 20-40% on lodging.
Are cheap pizza restaurant in Pigeon Forge still good quality?
Yes! All listings on our site are rated by real guests. Our budget picks maintain a minimum quality standard — we only show options with genuine positive reviews. A lower price doesn't mean lower quality.