TSM Verdict
The Verdict
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island is a casual, family-friendly pizzeria known for creative stone-baked pizzas, vegan options, and signature starters in a lively tourist setting. The menu features both classic and specialty pies, plus shareable appetizers and plant-based choices. Its main draw is the variety of pizzas and customizable options for different dietary needs.
Worth it?
Yes, especially if you are near Pigeon Forge.
Best order
Holy Shiitake Pie, Build Your Own Pizza, Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese, Kosmic Karma
Best time
Lunch or early dinner
Verify
Check current hours before driving.
Go For
- Holy Shiitake Pie
- Build Your Own Pizza
- Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese
- Kosmic Karma
- Mighty Meaty
Skip If
- You prefer a quiet, formal dining experience
- You're seeking low-cost or budget eats
- You want a menu focused on traditional Southern or local cuisine
Before You Go
Menu offerings and prices may vary slightly by franchise; confirm details and current hours on the official site.
Decision Guide
Decision Guide
Is it worth visiting?
It's a great choice for families, groups, or anyone craving inventive pizzas and plenty of vegan or vegetarian options in a fun, casual setting.
Best first order?
Holy Shiitake Pie, Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese, Build Your Own Pizza
Best time?
Worth driving from Gatlinburg or Pigeon Forge?
If you're looking for a wide variety of specialty and customizable pizzas—including vegan options—Mellow Mushroom Island stands out among chain pizzerias in the area.
Current concern?
Planner Snapshot
At a Glance
Location
Pigeon Forge, Tennessee
Cuisine
Pizza restaurant
Price
$$
Best meal
Lunch or early dinner
Families
Confirm fit before going
Planning fit
Best as part of a Pigeon Forge stop
Best For
Families looking for a casual dining experience • Pizza lovers seeking flavorful and fresh toppings • Visitors to The Island in Pigeon Forge wanting a quick, tasty meal
Website
mellowmushroom.comPro tip: Share multiple smaller pizzas among your group to try a variety of flavors and get the best value.
About Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Located in the bustling Island entertainment complex in Pigeon Forge, Mellow Mushroom offers a lively, art-filled atmosphere that stands out among local pizza restaurants. The walls showcase vibrant, psychedelic-inspired murals and funky decor that creates a laid-back, family-friendly vibe perfect for both tourists and locals.
The restaurant specializes in stone-baked pizzas with a distinctive Southern-style crust that's crispy on the outside and chewy inside. Their dough is made fresh daily using high-protein flour and Appalachian spring water, resulting in their signature flavor. While pizza is the star, the menu extends to hearty calzones, fresh salads, and hoagies.
Beer enthusiasts appreciate their rotating selection of craft brews, featuring both local Tennessee favorites and national craft offerings. The bar area provides a comfortable spot to watch sports or unwind after exploring The Island's attractions.
The spacious dining room accommodates larger groups and families, while the outdoor seating area offers views of The Island's fountains and activities. During peak tourist seasons, especially summer weekends and holidays, expect a 30-45 minute wait during prime dining hours.
Like other Mellow Mushroom locations, this Pigeon Forge restaurant maintains the chain's commitment to quality ingredients while incorporating local touches in both decor and menu options. Pizzas typically range from $15-30 depending on size and toppings, with lunch specials offering better value for budget-conscious diners.
For visitors seeking a reliable pizza option in Pigeon Forge that goes beyond basic chain offerings, Mellow Mushroom delivers consistent quality in a fun, welcoming environment that fits the area's tourist-friendly atmosphere.
Amenities & Features
- Signature crust and fresh, flavorful pizzas when properly prepared (Holy Shiitake and other specialty pizzas get specific praise)
- Prime location with great views of The Island's activity and energetic atmosphere
- Fast, friendly service during positive experiences with quick food delivery
- Earns approval from picky eaters, including visitors from pizza meccas like Buffalo, NY
Insider Tips for Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Insider tips
Share multiple smaller pizzas among your group to try a variety of flavors and get the best value.
Before you go
Current price guidance on this page is $$. A website is linked here for direct confirmation of current details.
Menu Guide
What to Order at Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Main
Holy Shiitake Pie
A specialty pizza with an olive-oil and garlic base, topped with shiitake, button, and portobello mushrooms, caramelized onions, mozzarella, MontAmoré cheese, finished with garlic aioli, black truffle oil, and fresh chives.
Main
Build Your Own Pizza
Stone-baked pizza where you choose the size, crust, sauce, cheeses, and toppings—including plant-based cheese and proteins—making it a flexible option for all diets.
Starter
Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese
Oven-baked dough bites tossed in garlic butter and Parmesan (or salted), served with a side of beer cheese; a frequently praised starter at this location.
Main
Kosmic Karma
A red-sauce pizza with mozzarella, feta, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and Roma tomatoes, finished with a pesto drizzle; a popular vegetarian choice.
Main
Mighty Meaty
A classic meat-lover’s pizza topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, ham, and applewood-smoked bacon.
Best For
- Families looking for a casual dining experience
- Pizza lovers seeking flavorful and fresh toppings
- Visitors to The Island in Pigeon Forge wanting a quick, tasty meal
Opening Hours
Best Times to Visit Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Check the restaurant's current seating policy before weekend evenings; popular spots can have waits.
Tags
Traveler Questions
What are the current hours for Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island?
Public hours on this listing show Friday 11 AM to 11 PM, Monday 11 AM to 10 PM, Sunday 11 AM to 10 PM, and additional days in the hours table. Call (865) 286-3800 before driving over if timing matters.
Where is Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island located?
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island is listed at 131 The Island Dr Ste 3101 Pigeon Forge TN 37863. Use the directions button for current routing, traffic, and drive time from your lodging.
Does Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island take reservations or call-ahead seating?
This listing does not have a verified reservation policy. Call ahead before peak lunch or dinner periods, especially if you are bringing a group or driving in from outside Pigeon Forge.
What should I order first at Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island?
Start with the most category-specific items on the current menu and ask about daily specials when you arrive. Check directly before driving if you need a specific dish.
Is Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island worth a detour from Gatlinburg or Pigeon Forge?
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island makes the most sense when you are already exploring Pigeon Forge or the east side of the Smokies. For most travelers, it is better as part of a local day trip than a standalone drive from the main tourist strip.
What should I know about parking, groups, or accessibility?
We do not have verified parking, group seating, or accessibility details for this listing yet. Call the business directly before arriving with an RV, trailer, large group, or specific accessibility needs.
More in Pigeon Forge
Nearby picks around Pigeon Forge
Related Guides
Explore More
Plan around Pigeon Forge
Explore Pigeon Forge attractions
Discover top-rated spots
Top-rated pizza restaurant in Pigeon Forge
More places to eat in Pigeon Forge
Browse Smoky Mountain dining
Coffee and quick bites
Where to eat
Compare the two towns