Duration
45-90 minutes (longer during peak dinner hours)
Price
$17-28 per pizza, expect $25-40 per person with drinks
Best For
Late-night diners looking for quality pizza after midnight • Families with gluten-free kids who want authentic options • Groups wanting authentic Jersey-style pizza in the Smokies
Pro Tip
Order your pizza online for pickup to skip the 40+ minute wait times, especially during peak dinner hours on weekends.
About Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge
We've been hitting up Jersey Hustle Pizzeria for years, and honestly, it's our go-to spot when we're craving authentic Jersey-style pizza in Pigeon Forge. This women-owned and veteran-owned family business serves up some seriously good thin-crust pies with generous toppings.
Their specialty pizzas are where they really shine - The Gotti white pizza with ricotta and spinach is incredible, and The Boardwalk loaded with sausage, meatballs, and bacon hits the spot every time. They've also got solid gluten-free and vegan options that actually taste good.
Fair warning: you'll pay tourist prices here, with small pizzas running $17-28, but the quality backs it up. The Pine Mountain location stays open until midnight, which is clutch when you need late-night eats.
We love that they've got outdoor seating and serve beer and wine. The staff always hooks our kids up with the TV remote to watch cartoons while we wait.
Just heads up - waits can stretch to over an hour during peak times, so ordering online ahead is your best bet.
Amenities & Features
Don't Miss
The Gotti White Pizza
This white pizza with ricotta, garlic, mozzarella, spinach, onions, and fresh basil is hands down our favorite. It's creamy, garlicky, and loaded with fresh ingredients that actually taste like they came from Jersey.
Late Night Hours
The Pine Mountain location stays open until midnight daily, making it one of the few quality pizza spots for late-night munchies. We've grabbed slices here after long days at Dollywood more times than we can count.
Cauliflower Crust Options
Their gluten-free cauliflower crust actually tastes good - not cardboard-y like most places. Parents consistently tell us their gluten-free kids devour these pizzas and ask to come back.
The Boardwalk Loaded Pizza
Packed with sausage, meatballs, bacon, green peppers, and onions, this pizza is serious business. It's messy, indulgent, and exactly what you want after a day in the Smokies.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere
The staff will hand over the TV remote so your kids can watch cartoons while you wait. They've got highchairs, outdoor seating for nice days, and genuinely seem to enjoy having families around.
Authentic Jersey Style
This isn't just tourist pizza with a Jersey name - it's the real deal with thin crust, quality ingredients, and that slightly charred bottom that makes Jersey pizza special. The owners clearly know what they're doing.
Know Before You Go
- Free parking available at both locations, but Pine Mountain Road has better availability
- Bring cash for tips and patience for waits - peak times can be brutal
- Order online ahead of time to minimize wait times, especially on weekends
- Indoor and outdoor seating available year-round with heaters
- Wheelchair accessible with highchairs available for families
Visitor Sentiment
Based on reviewsJersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge receives consistently positive feedback from visitors. Located in Pigeon Forge, it's a solid choice for the area.
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge Opening Hours
Best Times to Visit Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge
For the best dining experience, consider making reservations for weekend evenings.
Tags
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the hours for Jersey Hustle Pizzeria?
The Pine Mountain location is open daily from 10:30 AM to midnight, while the Waldens Creek location closes at 10:00 PM. These are some of the latest pizza hours in Pigeon Forge.
How much does Jersey Hustle Pizzeria cost?
Small cheese pizzas start around $17-19, while small gourmet pizzas run about $28. Expect to pay $80+ for two pizzas and three drinks - it's tourist pricing but the quality backs it up.
Do I need reservations for Jersey Hustle Pizzeria?
No reservations needed, but we strongly recommend ordering online for pickup. Walk-in waits can stretch 40 minutes to nearly 2 hours during busy times.
How long should I spend at Jersey Hustle Pizzeria?
Plan on 45-60 minutes if you're dining in, or about 30-45 minutes for pickup if you order ahead online. Peak times can double these estimates.
Is Jersey Hustle Pizzeria good for kids?
Absolutely - they've got highchairs, kid-friendly pizzas, and the staff will even give you the TV remote so kids can watch cartoons. Their cauliflower crust is great for gluten-free kids too.
Is there parking at Jersey Hustle Pizzeria?
Yes, both locations have free off-street parking available. The Pine Mountain Road location typically has better parking availability.
Do they have gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, they serve both gluten-free and cauliflower crust options that actually taste good. Parents consistently rave about how much their gluten-free kids love the cauliflower crust.
Can I bring my dog to Jersey Hustle Pizzeria?
Dogs are welcome in their outdoor seating areas at both locations. They're pretty pet-friendly for a pizza joint.
You May Also Like
More great places in Pigeon Forge
We use a weighted 10-point scoring system to evaluate the best places to visit and things to do in the Smokies.
Scoring is carefully evaluated based on reviews, social signals and expert assessments.
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge receives consistently positive feedback from visitors. Located in Pigeon Forge, it's a solid choice for the area.
Last Updated Dec 27, 2025
204 Pine Mountain Rd Pigeon Forge TN 37863
204 Pine Mountain Rd Pigeon Forge TN 37863
Pigeon Forge
Get Insider Tips
Sign up for local deals, hidden gems, and travel guides.