Showing 8 top-rated pizza restaurants • Updated October 2026
West by God CoalFired Pizza
The pineapple-and-bacon-jam pie comes out of the coal oven with a blistered, cracker-crisp crust, and the fried pickles and banana peppers vanish just as fast. West by God CoalFired Pizza pairs that New Haven-style cooking with a self-serve beer wall and on-site axe throwing, which makes it a better fit for groups and curious pizza hunters than for anyone after a quiet dinner.
Pizza-Rio - The Brazilian Way Pigeon Forge
Servers keep bringing fresh pizzas to your table, from Brazilian calabresa and stroganoff to chocolate and dulce de leche dessert slices, and window seats look out on the Smoky Mountains. It suits families, couples and anyone curious about Brazilian food, though some guests mention slow gaps between pizzas and disagree on the value.
Pizza at The Cove
Guests build their own pizza on a tablet at the counter, then wait for fresh pies alongside jalapeño poppers and garlic knots that reviewers single out. Friendly staff who remember returning visitors make this small Dollywood Lane spot a good fit for families, couples, and groups wanting a quick, casual meal; seating is limited, so carryout works well too.
J. Del's Pizza
Visitors rave about the New York-style pizza at J. Del's, a family-owned counter-service spot where the owners often chat with guests while orders cook. Garlic knots and Italian beef earn praise too. It suits East Coast transplants and families wanting an evening meal after a day of Pigeon Forge attractions; doors open at 4 PM.
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge
Instead of a basket of garlic knots, you get one oversized knot here—a fitting quirk for a pizzeria that loads its thin Jersey-style crust with real toppings and stays open until midnight. Slices are sold by the piece, and gluten-free and vegan options are genuine, not afterthoughts. Best for late-night eaters and families; order online, since peak waits can run 40 minutes.
Big Daddy's Pizzeria
The brick oven runs at 550 degrees, and you taste it in the blistered crust of specialty pies like the Great White and Mama Mia. Dough is made daily, wood-fired wings come by the pound, and an arcade keeps kids occupied. Good fit for families, big groups, and anyone wanting a casual meal off the tourist treadmill.
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge
Spinach artichoke dip, pretzel bites and Holy Shiitake pizza are what diners keep mentioning at this Parkway pizzeria, along with craft beers on tap and dependable vegan and gluten-free crusts. Ordering happens at the counter in a casual, trippy-decor room that suits families and groups grabbing a quick bite or a to-go order between attractions.
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Visitors single out the signature crust and specialty pies like the Holy Shiitake, ordered at the counter and brought to your table with views of The Island's bustle. It suits families, groups sharing several smaller pizzas, and anyone wanting a quick bite between attractions; go early or on weekdays, since evenings get busy and the menu is trimmer than other locations.
What the numbers say
- Across 8 reviewed pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge, visitors have left 20,143 reviews — 8 of 8 hold a 4-star average or better.
- Highest-rated: West by God CoalFired Pizza at 4.7 stars (1,219 reviews).
- Most-reviewed: Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge with 7,470 reviews at 4.4 stars — the crowd favorite and the top-rated pick aren't the same place here, which usually means the popular one trades a little polish for location or price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge?
Based on our TSM Score™ rankings, West by God CoalFired Pizza is currently the top-rated pizza restaurant in Pigeon Forge with a rating of 4.7 from 1,219 reviews.
How many pizza restaurants are there in Pigeon Forge?
We currently track 8 Pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge, all rated and reviewed by real visitors. Our list is updated regularly as new businesses open and reviews come in.
When is the best time to visit pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge?
The best time depends on your trip style. Peak weekends bring the most demand, while weekdays and shoulder seasons are usually easier for parking, reservations, and better lodging value.
Explore More
Ready to Plan Your Pigeon Forge Stop?
Browse all 8 options, compare prices, read reviews, and lock in the part of the trip people usually delay too long.