Showing 8 top-rated pizza restaurants • Updated June 2026
West by God CoalFired Pizza
West by God CoalFired Pizza delivers excellent wood-fired pizza with a crispy crust that guests rave about, plus the unique addition of on-site axe throwing. The beer wall concept and live music on Friday nights create a fun, lively atmosphere. However, service can be maddeningly inconsistent—some servers are exceptional while others barely acknowledge guests, and delivery orders have experienced significant problems with wrong orders and multi-hour delays.
Pizza-Rio - The Brazilian Way Pigeon Forge
Pizza-Rio brings authentic Brazilian rodízio-style dining to Pigeon Forge, where servers continuously bring different pizza varieties to your table. Most visitors rave about the unique flavor combinations, beautiful mountain-view atmosphere, and the novelty of the all-you-can-eat Brazilian pizza experience. However, opinions on value are divided—while some find the $33 per person price reasonable for unlimited pizza, others feel the quality doesn't justify the cost, with a few comparing it unfav
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge
This Jersey-style pizzeria off the main Parkway delivers authentic thin-crust pizza that keeps visitors coming back for seconds—literally, with multiple reviewers returning during the same trip. The generous toppings and late-night hours earn consistent praise, though you'll pay tourist-area prices (expect $22+ for a small pizza). A few visitors have encountered significant customer service issues and online ordering problems that warrant caution.
Pizza at The Cove
Easygoing eatery with wood furnishings & a take-out option turning out pizzas, wings & sides.
J. Del's Pizza
Modest pizzeria & restaurant offering pasta, subs, calzones & other casual Italian eats.
Big Daddy's Pizzeria
Local chain offering wood-fired, thin-crust pies, plus sandwiches & salads, in a casual setting.
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge
Experience creative specialty pizzas and hearty starters at Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge, a family-friendly pizzeria with a lively atmosphere.
Mellow Mushroom Pigeon Forge Island
Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge?
Based on our TSM Score™ rankings, West by God CoalFired Pizza is currently the top-rated pizza restaurant in Pigeon Forge with a rating of 4.7 from 1,219 reviews.
How many pizza restaurants are there in Pigeon Forge?
We currently track 8 Pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge, all rated and reviewed by real visitors. Our list is updated regularly as new businesses open and reviews come in.
When is the best time to visit pizza restaurants in Pigeon Forge?
The best time depends on your trip style. Peak weekends bring the most demand, while weekdays and shoulder seasons are usually easier for parking, reservations, and better lodging value.
Explore More
Ready to Plan Your Pigeon Forge Stop?
Browse all 8 options, compare prices, read reviews, and lock in the part of the trip people usually delay too long.