J. Del's Pizza

When locals crave authentic New York-style pizza in Pigeon Forge, J. Del's Pizza delivers the closest thing to a genuine East Coast slice you'll find in the Smokies. The hand-tossed dough and triangle-cut pies channel Brooklyn's finest, while their Chicago-style thin crust (cut in squares) offers a tasty alternative that sets them apart from other pizza restaurants in the area.

What makes J. Del's special is their commitment to pizza fundamentals - from the perfectly crispy crust to generous toppings. During lunch hours (11 AM-2 PM), they offer pizza by the slice, a rare find in Pigeon Forge that's perfect for tourists wanting a quick bite between attractions. The BYOB policy means you can bring your favorite wine to complement your meal, and the dog-friendly outdoor seating makes it ideal for families traveling with pets.

While the interior is simple and straightforward, the focus here is squarely on the food. The restaurant stays open late (until 11 PM on weekends), making it a convenient stop after shows and evening activities on the Parkway. Beyond pizza, their menu includes classic Italian favorites like calzones, pasta, and subs.

Be prepared for potential wait times during peak tourist seasons - the pickup system can get backed up when they're busy. Most locals recommend calling ahead for takeout orders, especially on weekends. While the dining room might not win any design awards, J. Del's Pizza has earned its reputation by consistently serving some of the most authentic New York-style pizza you'll find in the Smoky Mountains.