Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge
Pigeon Forge • Pizza restaurant
This Jersey-style pizzeria off the main Parkway delivers authentic thin-crust pizza that keeps visitors coming back for seconds—literally, with multiple reviewers returning during the same trip. The generous toppings and late-night hours earn consistent praise, though you'll pay tourist-area prices (expect $22+ for a small pizza). A few visitors have encountered significant customer service issues and online ordering problems that warrant caution.
Reviews
1,355
Price Level
$$
West by God CoalFired Pizza
Pigeon Forge • Pizza restaurant
West by God CoalFired Pizza delivers excellent wood-fired pizza with a crispy crust that guests rave about, plus the unique addition of on-site axe throwing. The beer wall concept and live music on Friday nights create a fun, lively atmosphere. However, service can be maddeningly inconsistent—some servers are exceptional while others barely acknowledge guests, and delivery orders have experienced significant problems with wrong orders and multi-hour delays.
Reviews
1,219
Price Level
$$
Amenities & Features
| Feature | Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge | West by God CoalFired Pizza |
|---|---|---|
| Thin-crust pizza loaded with toppings, not the skimpy portions typical of tourist traps | ||
| Open late when most Pigeon Forge restaurants have closed for the night | ||
| Strip mall location makes it easy to access without battling Parkway traffic | ||
| Oversized garlic knot (singular) instead of traditional garlic knots—a unique twist | ||
| Coal-fired pizza with perfectly crispy crust, particularly the pineapple with bacon jam variety | ||
| Self-serve beer wall with great selection | ||
| Axe throwing available on-site adds entertainment value | ||
| Fried pickles and banana peppers appetizers are crowd favorites |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge or West by God CoalFired Pizza better?
Based on our TSM Score, West by God CoalFired Pizza ranks higher (9.4 vs 9.0). Both are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains.
What are the main differences between Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge and West by God CoalFired Pizza?
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge is located in Pigeon Forge and categorized as Pizza restaurant with a $$ price range. West by God CoalFired Pizza is in Pigeon Forge and categorized as Pizza restaurant with a $$ price range. Check the amenities comparison above for a detailed feature-by-feature breakdown.
Where can I book Jersey Hustle Pizzeria Pigeon Forge or West by God CoalFired Pizza?
You can view detailed information and booking options for both properties on TheSmokyMountains.com. Visit each listing page for the latest availability, photos, and guest reviews.