TSM Verdict
The Verdict
Johnny Carino's in Pigeon Forge is a casual regional chain Italian restaurant known for its hearty pasta dishes and signature baked lasagna. The menu features a range of classic and specialty Italian-American comfort foods, with options for both individual and group dining.
Worth it?
Yes, especially if you are near Pigeon Forge.
Best order
Italian Nachos, Johnny’s Fresh Baked Lasagna, Spicy Shrimp & Chicken, Spicy Romano Chicken
Best time
Lunch or early dinner
Verify
Check current hours before driving.
Go For
- Johnny’s Fresh Baked Lasagna
- Italian Nachos
- Spicy Shrimp & Chicken
- Classic Chicken Parmesan
- Pecan Chicken Salad
Skip If
- You want a unique, chef-driven or locally exclusive dining experience
- You prefer non-chain or non-Italian cuisine
- You are seeking a budget meal, as typical entrées run about $14–$21
Before You Go
Typical entrées range from about $14–$21 before tax and tip; check the official site for current menu and pricing.
Decision Guide
Decision Guide
Is it worth visiting?
Johnny Carino’s is a good fit for travelers seeking familiar Italian-American fare in a casual setting, especially if you’re already staying in or passing through Pigeon Forge. It’s best for those who enjoy classic pasta dishes and chain-restaurant consistency.
Best first order?
Johnny’s Fresh Baked Lasagna, Italian Nachos, Spicy Shrimp & Chicken, Classic Chicken Parmesan, or Pecan Chicken Salad
Worth driving from Gatlinburg or Pigeon Forge?
It’s a convenient stop if you’re already in Pigeon Forge or nearby, but not a must-drive destination from Gatlinburg, as the menu and experience are similar to other Johnny Carino’s locations.
Planner Snapshot
At a Glance
Location
Pigeon Forge, Tennessee
Cuisine
Restaurant
Price
$$
Best meal
Lunch or early dinner
Families
Confirm fit before going
Planning fit
Best as part of a Pigeon Forge stop
Duration
1-2 hours for a meal
Price
$12.99 - $20.99 for main dishes
Best For
Families looking for large portions • Groups wanting affordable dining • Visitors seeking a quiet atmosphere
Website
carinos.comPro tip: Order the 'Create Your Own Pasta' base with toppings to maximize value from large portions.
About Johnny Carino's
We've eaten at Johnny Carino's probably a dozen times over the years, and honestly, it's become our go-to when we need to feed a big group without breaking the bank. The portions are absolutely massive — like, plan on taking half your meal home massive. Their wood-fired pizzas are solid, especially Johnny's Favorite loaded with everything, but don't sleep on the pasta dishes either.
The bread service hits different here. They bring out warm herb bread with olive oil right when you sit down, and it's unlimited, but seriously pace yourself because the entrées are no joke size-wise.
Location-wise, it's right on the Parkway at 2425, so parking can be a nightmare during peak times. We've learned to either get there by 5:30 for dinner or just call ahead for takeout when the strip is packed. The dining room stays pretty quiet even with TVs going, which is nice when you're trying to actually have a conversation.
One thing though — if you're thinking this is just another chain restaurant, you're not wrong, but the portions make it worth it for families. The Create Your Own Pasta for $12.99 plus toppings is probably the best value on the menu, and you can easily split it between two people. Just know that Friday and Saturday nights after 6 PM turn into a tourist zoo, so plan accordingly.
Amenities & Features
- Massive portions that reliably provide leftovers for another meal
- Italian nachos (especially with chicken) and stuffed vegetarian mushrooms are standout menu items
- Exceptionally attentive service, including accommodating Crohn's disease and other dietary restrictions
- Fresh, homemade bread served with meals
Insider Tips for Johnny Carino's
Insider tips
Visitors most often point to Massive Portions, Wood-Fired Pizzas, and Quiet Atmosphere. Plan to arrive early on weekends to avoid long wait times.
Consider calling ahead for takeout during peak tourist times. Be aware that parking can be challenging during busy hours.
Before you go
Plan around 1-2 hours for a meal unless you are only stopping in briefly. Current price guidance on this page is $12.99 - $20.99 for main dishes.
A website is linked here for direct confirmation of current details.
From the reviews
Visitors frequently mention the massive portion sizes that often lead to leftovers.
The warm herb bread served at the beginning is a common highlight in reviews.
Many reviewers appreciate the quiet atmosphere, even with TVs present.
Menu Guide
What to Order at Johnny Carino's
Starter
Italian Nachos
Crispy pasta chips topped with black olives, pepperoncini, Roma tomatoes, jalapeños, Alfredo sauce, Mozzarella and Parmesan, with your choice of chicken, sausage, or both; can be ordered 'Johnny’s Style' with green chile jalapeño Alfredo sauce for extra heat.
Main
Johnny’s Fresh Baked Lasagna
Layers of pasta, Italian sausage, beef, meat sauce, ricotta, Mozzarella and Parmesan, offered as an entrée or in a platter serving 2–3 people; a signature dish featured across multiple menu sections.
Main
Spicy Shrimp & Chicken
Penne sautéed with shrimp, sliced chicken, cayenne pepper, Romano cream sauce, mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes and green onions; a specialty pasta available in both lunch and dinner portions.
Main
Spicy Romano Chicken
Bowtie pasta sautéed with sliced chicken, cayenne pepper, Romano cream sauce, mushrooms, artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes and green onions; a named specialty pasta.
Main
Classic Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine tossed in Alfredo or green chile jalapeño Alfredo sauce, with options to add chicken or shrimp; a versatile base pasta featured on both lunch and dinner menus.
Main
Classic Chicken Parmesan
Breaded, baked chicken Parmesan with tomato sauce and Mozzarella, served with a side of spaghetti and tomato sauce; also available in combination plates.
Main
Pecan Chicken Salad
Fresh spinach, Gorgonzola, Roma tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, red onions, candied pecans and crispy onion straws in a warm bacon vinaigrette, topped with handmade chicken Parmesan.
Main
Johnny’s Combo
A combination plate featuring Johnny’s Fresh Baked Lasagna, Classic Chicken Parmesan, and spaghetti with tomato sauce; highlighted as a signature entrée.
Best For
- Families looking for large portions
- Groups wanting affordable dining
- Visitors seeking a quiet atmosphere
Know Before You Go
- Plan to arrive early on weekends to avoid long wait times.
- Consider calling ahead for takeout during peak tourist times.
- Be aware that parking can be challenging during busy hours.
- Check for daily specials that may not be listed on the menu.
- Consider visiting during off-peak hours for a quieter experience.
What Visitors Say
Featured from 3,745 reviewsVisitors frequently mention the massive portion sizes that often lead to leftovers.
Opening Hours
Best Times to Visit Johnny Carino's
Check the restaurant's current seating policy before weekend evenings; popular spots can have waits.
Tags
Traveler Questions
Does it offer highchairs for toddlers?
Yes.
Is parking available?
Yes, on-site.
Are there TVs?
Yes.
What are the typical wait times?
Plan to arrive early on weekends to avoid long wait times.
Is takeout available?
Yes, consider calling ahead during peak tourist times.
What is the price range for main dishes?
Typical entrées range from about $14–$21 before tax and tip.
More in Pigeon Forge
Nearby picks around Pigeon Forge
Related Guides
Explore More
Plan around Pigeon Forge
Explore Pigeon Forge attractions
Discover top-rated spots
Top-rated restaurant in Pigeon Forge
More places to eat in Pigeon Forge
Browse Smoky Mountain dining
Coffee and quick bites
Where to eat
Compare the two towns