Colima Mexican Restaurant
Sylva • Mexican restaurant
Colima has been a Sylva institution for years, earning devoted regulars who appreciate the friendly service and wallet-friendly prices—especially the weekday buffets and $1.25 Taco Tuesdays. However, recent visits show an inconsistent experience, with some reporting declining food quality and service issues, while others continue to have excellent meals. The interior could use updating, and there are occasional service missteps that stand out against otherwise positive interactions.
Reviews
944
Price Level
$
Lucy in the Rye
Sylva • Family restaurant
Lucy in the Rye has earned a devoted following for its outstanding breakfast and brunch, with visitors consistently praising the creative menu and bold seasoning. The Cajun sausage gravy, chicken bacon jam biscuit, and quiche are standout dishes that keep people coming back—some even make it an annual tradition. While the food quality is generally excellent, there have been occasional issues with temperature consistency, with a few dishes arriving less than piping hot.
Reviews
765
Price Level
$$
Amenities & Features
| Feature | Colima Mexican Restaurant | Lucy in the Rye |
|---|---|---|
| Lunch and Wednesday night buffets offer great value with good variety | ||
| Taco Tuesday specials at $1.25 draw consistent crowds | ||
| Chicken Tortilla Soup and Poker Plate get specific praise from regulars | ||
| Long-time community staple with many repeat customers who visit multiple times monthly | ||
| Signature items like the Cajun sausage gravy and biscuits, chicken bacon jam biscuit, and perfectly seasoned potatoes | ||
| Exceptional quiche with custard-like texture and flaky crust, plus standout smothered fried chicken | ||
| Friendly, personable service from servers who make guests feel welcome and go above and beyond | ||
| Everything is well-seasoned without being overly salty, including the seared greens and corned beef hash |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Colima Mexican Restaurant or Lucy in the Rye better?
Based on our TSM Score, Lucy in the Rye ranks higher (9.4 vs 8.8). Both are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains.
What are the main differences between Colima Mexican Restaurant and Lucy in the Rye?
Colima Mexican Restaurant is located in Sylva and categorized as Mexican restaurant with a $ price range. Lucy in the Rye is in Sylva and categorized as Family restaurant with a $$ price range. Check the amenities comparison above for a detailed feature-by-feature breakdown.
Where can I book Colima Mexican Restaurant or Lucy in the Rye?
You can view detailed information and booking options for both properties on TheSmokyMountains.com. Visit each listing page for the latest availability, photos, and guest reviews.