Lucy in the Rye - Family restaurant in Sylva
TSM PickFamily restaurant2.0

Lucy in the Rye

Sylva612 W Main St Sylva NC 28779
9.5
Outstanding

Best For

Families • Couples • Solo travelers

Pro Tip

Try the specialty waffle sandwich or avocado toast for a unique flavor experience

About Lucy in the Rye

Lucy in the Rye has earned a devoted following for its outstanding breakfast and brunch, with visitors consistently praising the creative menu and bold seasoning. The Cajun sausage gravy, chicken bacon jam biscuit, and quiche are standout dishes that keep people coming back—some even make it an annual tradition. While the food quality is generally excellent, there have been occasional issues with temperature consistency, with a few dishes arriving less than piping hot.

Amenities & Features

Signature items like the Cajun sausage gravy and biscuits, chicken bacon jam biscuit, and perfectly seasoned potatoesExceptional quiche with custard-like texture and flaky crust, plus standout smothered fried chickenFriendly, personable service from servers who make guests feel welcome and go above and beyondEverything is well-seasoned without being overly salty, including the seared greens and corned beef hash

Visitor Sentiment

Based on reviews

Lucy in the Rye receives consistently positive feedback from visitors. Located in Sylva, it's a solid choice for the area.

Lucy in the Rye Opening Hours

Monday7:45 AM to 2 PM
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday7:45 AM to 2 PM
Thursday7:45 AM to 2 PM
Friday7:45 AM to 2 PM
Saturday7:45 AM to 2 PM
Sunday7:45 AM to 2 PM

Best Times to Visit Lucy in the Rye

For the best dining experience, consider making reservations for weekend evenings.

🔥Buzzing
Weekend dinner rush 5PM - 8PM
☀️Relaxed
Tuesday & Wednesday evenings

Tags

Highly Reviewed

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the hours for Lucy in the Rye?

Check our opening hours section for current times. Hours may vary seasonally.

Is Lucy in the Rye family-friendly?

Yes, Lucy in the Rye welcomes visitors of all ages. It's a popular destination for families visiting Sylva.

How do I get to Lucy in the Rye?

Lucy in the Rye is located at 612 W Main St Sylva NC 28779. Use the directions button for navigation.

Does Lucy in the Rye take reservations?

We recommend calling ahead or checking their website for reservation options, especially on weekends.

You May Also Like

More great places in Sylva

View all
TSM Verified
9.5/10

We use a weighted 10-point scoring system to evaluate the best places to visit and things to do in the Smokies.

Scoring is carefully evaluated based on reviews, social signals and expert assessments.

Food Quality
8.94
👤Service
9.14
🏛️Ambience
8.85
💰Value
8.46
Public Review Sentiment
Based on 765 Reviews

Lucy in the Rye receives consistently positive feedback from visitors. Located in Sylva, it's a solid choice for the area.

Last Updated Dec 27, 2025

Call Website
Directions
Address

612 W Main St Sylva NC 28779

612 W Main St Sylva NC 28779

Sylva

View larger map

Get Insider Tips

Sign up for local deals, hidden gems, and travel guides.