Head-to-Head Comparison

Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza vs Bella

Compare ratings, prices, amenities, and reviews to make the best choice for your Smoky Mountains trip

Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza
8.8

Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza

GatlinburgItalian restaurant

Casual spot for New York-style pizzas plus calzones, garlic rolls & other Italian standards.

Reviews

3,703

Price Level

$$

Bella
9.2

Bella

MaryvilleItalian restaurant

Bella has earned a devoted following in Maryville for delivering an upscale Italian dining experience that consistently impresses. Visitors rave about the tableside pasta prepared in a cheese wheel—a theatrical dish that tastes as authentic as what you'd find in Italy. The service stands out remarkably, with multiple servers mentioned by name for their attentiveness and professionalism. The sophisticated atmosphere makes it a go-to spot for celebrations, from rehearsal dinners to anniversaries.

Reviews

1,234

Price Level

$$

Amenities & Features

FeatureBest Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks PlazaBella
Thin-crust pizzas with crunchy bottoms and chewy centers, especially the Spicy Italian and Italian Flag varieties
Outstanding antipasto salad and homemade marinara sauce that won't upset your stomach
Generous portions that leave leftovers—even splitting dishes like lasagna leaves food to spare
Garlic rolls that regulars call 'the bomb' and exceptional Chicken Florentine
Tableside pasta in the cheese wheel—a signature dish that guests say tastes authentically Italian and is worth ordering
Exceptional service from attentive servers like Teri Lyn, Presley, Meraya, and Elijah who elevate the dining experience
Standout appetizers, particularly the house-made arancini and Brussels sprouts that keep guests coming back
Upscale, decadent atmosphere perfect for special occasions and celebrations

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza or Bella better?

Based on our TSM Score, Bella ranks higher (9.2 vs 8.8). Both are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains.

What are the main differences between Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza and Bella?

Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza is located in Gatlinburg and categorized as Italian restaurant with a $$ price range. Bella is in Maryville and categorized as Italian restaurant with a $$ price range. Check the amenities comparison above for a detailed feature-by-feature breakdown.

Where can I book Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza or Bella?

You can view detailed information and booking options for both properties on TheSmokyMountains.com. Visit each listing page for the latest availability, photos, and guest reviews.

Explore More

The Verdict

Both Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Elks Plaza and Bella are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains. Bella has a higher TSM Score (9.2 vs 8.8), making it the top pick based on guest ratings.