The Old Mill Pottery House Café

The Old Mill Pottery House Café delivers authentic Southern cooking in Pigeon Forge's historic Old Mill District, where every meal arrives on handmade pottery crafted right next door. Set in a converted 1954 potter's residence, this restaurant combines local history with fresh, made-from-scratch cooking that draws both tourists and locals.

What sets this place apart is their use of fresh-ground grains from the neighboring Old Mill, which you'll taste in their warm bread baskets and house-baked desserts. The menu focuses on Southern comfort classics, featuring perfectly-cooked steaks and fresh seafood dishes. Their outdoor garden seating, complete with a peaceful fountain, makes an ideal spot for their popular weekend brunch service.

The restaurant operates on a first-come, first-served basis without reservations. While wait times can stretch during peak dinner hours (especially during tourist season), they typically move faster than at the main Old Mill Restaurant. Prices run slightly lower here too, making it a smart choice for families wanting quality Southern food without the premium pricing.

After your meal, take advantage of the walkable Old Mill District. Watch potters at work next door, grab dessert at the creamery, or explore the various craft shops. Free parking is available in the shared district lot.

For the best experience, consider visiting during off-peak hours or weekdays when crowds are lighter. The outdoor seating area becomes particularly pleasant during spring and fall months, though indoor tables offer cozy year-round comfort with views of the district's historic architecture.