Head-to-Head Comparison

The Island in Pigeon Forge vs The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof

Compare ratings, prices, amenities, and reviews to make the best choice for your Smoky Mountains trip

The Island in Pigeon Forge
9.4

The Island in Pigeon Forge

Pigeon ForgeAmusement park

Playful destination featuring unique shops, casual restaurants & amusement rides, plus a hotel.

Reviews

59,032

The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof
9.2

The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof

Pigeon ForgeAmusement park

Popular mountainside amusement park offers a roller coaster, goat petting zoo & a sweet shop.

Reviews

6,420

Amenities & Features

FeatureThe Island in Pigeon ForgeThe Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof
Spectacular fountain and light shows that captivate visitors for extended periods
Outstanding holiday decorations and festive atmosphere with beautiful lights and music
Variety of activities including rides and entertainment options
Exceptionally helpful and courteous staff throughout the property
Exceptionally fast speeds compared to other Smoky Mountain coasters—perfect for thrill-seekers
Staff goes above and beyond, especially with special needs visitors and large youth groups
Less crowded than other Pigeon Forge attractions, with lines that move quickly
Bonus attraction of feeding goats after your ride

Frequently Asked Questions

Is The Island in Pigeon Forge or The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof better?

Based on our TSM Score, The Island in Pigeon Forge ranks higher (9.4 vs 9.2). The Island in Pigeon Forge has 59,032 reviews with a 4.7 rating, while The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof has 6,420 reviews with a 4.6 rating.

What are the main differences between The Island in Pigeon Forge and The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof?

The Island in Pigeon Forge is located in Pigeon Forge and categorized as Amusement park. The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof is in Pigeon Forge and categorized as Amusement park. Check the amenities comparison above for a detailed feature-by-feature breakdown.

Where can I book The Island in Pigeon Forge or The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof?

You can view detailed information and booking options for both properties on TheSmokyMountains.com. Visit each listing page for the latest availability, photos, and guest reviews.

Explore More

The Verdict

Both The Island in Pigeon Forge and The Goat Coaster at Goats on the Roof are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains. The Island in Pigeon Forge has a higher TSM Score (9.4 vs 9.2), making it the top pick based on guest ratings.