Head-to-Head Comparison

Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg vs Pizzeria of Gatlinburg

Compare ratings, prices, amenities, and reviews to make the best choice for your Smoky Mountains trip

Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg
8.4

Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg

GatlinburgPizza restaurant

Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas.

Reviews

4,094

Price Level

$$

Pizzeria of Gatlinburg
8.8

Pizzeria of Gatlinburg

GatlinburgPizza restaurant

Cabin-like diner known for New York-style pizza with creative toppings, plus pasta and hot sandwiches.

Reviews

4,051

Price Level

$$

Amenities & Features

FeatureMellow Mushroom GatlinburgPizzeria of Gatlinburg
Colorful, artistic atmosphere with a fun, quirky vibe that feels cozy in the mountains
Excellent pizza selection with quality vegetarian options like the Veggie Delite
Dedicated servers (particularly Zion, Rhonda, Shak, and Mirt) who provide attentive, friendly service
Cool downstairs bar with daiquiris and convenient location near bluegrass music venues
Pizza that genuinely compares to hometown favorites, with a standout sauce that's flavorful yet easy on the stomach
Lightning-fast delivery service—calzones and pizzas arriving in 25 minutes instead of the estimated 45-90 minutes
Large portions and good value pricing for a tourist area, especially with weekly online specials
Friendly, efficient staff who keep the service moving with minimal wait times

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg or Pizzeria of Gatlinburg better?

Based on our TSM Score, Pizzeria of Gatlinburg ranks higher (8.8 vs 8.4). Both are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains.

What are the main differences between Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg and Pizzeria of Gatlinburg?

Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg is located in Gatlinburg and categorized as Pizza restaurant with a $$ price range. Pizzeria of Gatlinburg is in Gatlinburg and categorized as Pizza restaurant with a $$ price range. Check the amenities comparison above for a detailed feature-by-feature breakdown.

Where can I book Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg or Pizzeria of Gatlinburg?

You can view detailed information and booking options for both properties on TheSmokyMountains.com. Visit each listing page for the latest availability, photos, and guest reviews.

More about Mellow Mushroom GatlinburgMore about Pizzeria of GatlinburgBest Pizza restaurant in Gatlinburg

The Verdict

Both Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg and Pizzeria of Gatlinburg are excellent choices in the Smoky Mountains. Pizzeria of Gatlinburg has a higher TSM Score (8.8 vs 8.4), making it the top pick based on guest ratings.