Maggie Valley guide

Cafe Italiano Restaurant & Pizzeria in Maggie Valley: tickets, hours & planning tips

Maggie Valley has one italian restaurant: Cafe Italiano Restaurant & Pizzeria. This guide pulls together what visitors most want to know — tickets, hours, what to expect, parking, and how to plan the rest of the day around it — without pretending this is a competitive ranking.

Check Availability & Prices

Lock in live hotel or cabin rates for Maggie Valley before weekend inventory gets tighter.

Live Rates

Type dates as MM/DD/YYYY or use a quick date above.

2 nights stay • Compare live rates before the best-value rooms disappear

Compare on Booking.com
Also compare:Booking.comHotels.comExpediaVrbo
✓ Live rates✓ Guest checkout✓ Best price comparison

Showing 1 top-rated italian restaurants • Updated June 2026

Cafe Italiano Restaurant & Pizzeria in Maggie Valley
#1 Top Rated
8.7

Cafe Italiano Restaurant & Pizzeria

This cozy strip-mall Italian spot delivers genuine home-style cooking that wins over most visitors, with the thin-crust pizza, carbonara, and lasagna earning particularly enthusiastic praise. The intimate setting features limited seating and a friendly, personable owner who often checks on diners. However, recent reviews hint at operational struggles—understaffing has led to inconsistent service times and occasional quality issues, with one reviewer noting the restaurant is up for sale.

Maggie Valley913 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best italian restaurants in Maggie Valley?

Based on our TSM Score™ rankings, Cafe Italiano Restaurant & Pizzeria is currently the top-rated italian restaurant in Maggie Valley with a rating of 4.2 from 913 reviews.

How many italian restaurants are there in Maggie Valley?

We currently track 1 Italian restaurant in Maggie Valley, all rated and reviewed by real visitors. Our list is updated regularly as new businesses open and reviews come in.

When is the best time to visit italian restaurants in Maggie Valley?

The best time depends on your trip style. Peak weekends bring the most demand, while weekdays and shoulder seasons are usually easier for parking, reservations, and better lodging value.

Explore More

Best Italian Restaurant in GatlinburgBest Italian Restaurant in Pigeon ForgeBudget Italian Restaurant in Maggie ValleyTravel Guides

Ready to Plan Your Maggie Valley Stop?

Browse all 1 options, compare prices, read reviews, and lock in the part of the trip people usually delay too long.

Check Availability Compare on Booking.com
Also compare:Booking.comHotels.comExpediaVrbo