1 Ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge

Best Ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge

Looking for the best ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge? We've ranked 1 options using our TSM Score™ algorithm, which combines guest ratings, review volume, and expert analysis. Whether you're planning a weekend getaway or a week-long vacation, this guide has everything you need to make the right choice.

Check Availability & Prices

✓ Best Price Guarantee✓ No Booking Fees✓ Instant Confirmation

Showing 1 top-rated ice cream shop • Updated March 2026

Old Mill Creamery in Pigeon Forge
#1 Top Rated
8.6

Old Mill Creamery

Ice cream parlor with a mix of classic & signature flavors, plus cookies & to-go sandwiches.

Pigeon Forge357 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge?

Based on our TSM Score™ rankings, Old Mill Creamery is currently the top-rated ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge with a rating of 4.4 from 357 reviews.

How many ice cream shop are there in Pigeon Forge?

We currently track 1 ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge, all rated and reviewed by real visitors. Our list is updated regularly as new businesses open and reviews come in.

When is the best time to visit ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge?

The best time depends on your preferences. Fall (October-November) offers stunning foliage but larger crowds. Spring (April-May) brings wildflowers and mild weather. Summer is peak season with the most options available. Winter offers lower prices and fewer crowds.

Explore More

Best Restaurants in Pigeon ForgeBest Hotels in Pigeon ForgeBest Attractions in Pigeon ForgeBest Cabins in Pigeon ForgeBest Hiking Trails in Pigeon ForgeThings to Do in Pigeon ForgeBest Ice Cream Shop in GatlinburgBest Ice Cream Shop in SeviervilleBest Ice Cream Shop in TownsendBest Ice Cream Shop in CherokeeBest Ice Cream Shop in Bryson CityBest Ice Cream Shop in Wears Valley

Ready to Book Your Ice cream shop in Pigeon Forge?

Browse all 1 options, compare prices, read reviews, and book directly.